Question, turn 403:
All -- I've read that once you have an AE in a skill area you don't need to use a tactic in that area. What if you have a favorite tactic? Would it benefit your warrior to use it even if he is maxed in that area? -- Hanibal's Q.O.W.
Answers, turn 404:
Q.O.W. -- Tactics. It's generally believed that using a tactic, at any level of skill, increases something (init, attack, damage, etc. though no one's sure) at the expense of one or more other abilities. Usually it seems you lose more for using the tactic than you gain, so they should be used sparingly. However, favorite tactics are a bit different. I've noticed, generally, that the penalties usually imposed by using the tactic are greatly reduced or eliminated, making it more useful. I run a piker in AD who has response as a favorite and run her with it. She seems to do great with it against everybody. My decise running striker still defends well (though she's got favorite learn defense), and she still jumps everyone with a poor decise rating. My advice is to give it a try if it's a tactic you think your warrior needs, or can use based on their current point of development. -- Adie
Hanibal -- It really is almost like flicking a switch the way you can (usually) prevent death intent statements if you want to. Dartor is the arena expert on killing and he too agrees. Most new managers gain pleasure from seeing their warriors kill, and it's not something to be ashamed of. But there is a better way of going about things. I think as you gain more experience and experiment with lower KD, you'll find that running with a 4 where you used to run with a 6 will have little effect on a warrior's performance other than decreasing the chance of death intent. This is especially true in the first minute, or before your warrior would get tired. -- Generalissimo Puerco
Hanibal -- Each tactic has some benefits and some drawbacks. I can't tell you exactly what those are because I don't know myself. If a tactic only provided the equivalent of extra skills, then it might be true that a warrior wouldn't need them after a certain level of skill is achieved. But let's say that your warrior has an AE+3 and his opponent has a MA. Then there might still be good cause to use a tactic.
I believe tactics grant benefits that can't always be translated into more skills. I think the best example of this is what happens when response is used against decise. Tactics have their value at all levels of the game, but the most valuable tactics might change. I don't think many would run with decise at the top of AD, though lunge and dodge remain popular. But for a new warrior, decise can be very important. Tactics are not well documented in the literature, and for that reason you may do well to learn first-hand and develop some instincts regarding the use of appropriate tactics. -- Generalissimo Puerco
Hanibal -- Regarding the latest question: if you have an advanced expert in an area that equates to a given tactic, is there any point in running the tactic. Yes, if the tactic is a useful one. I don't THINK that there is a one-to-one equivalence between types of skills and types of tactics. For one thing, there are eight tactics and only six types of skills! -- Leeta
Question, turn 404:
All -- Do you think you are faster with your favorite weapon? If your fav is a Halberd would you be quicker with a War Hammer? I've read you get +4 in each area if you are using your favorite. -- Hanibal's Q.O.W.
Answers, turn 405:
Hanibal -- I strongly doubt that a favorite weapon gives four extra skills in each category. I don't see how anyone could know that unless it was said by a credible source within the GC. I'm terrible at finding favorite weapons. I can tell you that the one large favorite weapon I've had experience with is the greatsword, and it is still lousy even as a favorite. I really enjoy longsword as a favorite. -- Generalissimo Puerco
Q.O.W. -- With regard to favorites, the only really obvious effect is that you are automatically well suited to it, and the warrior using it almost always throws more critical attacks with that weapon than if it wasn't their favorite. That pretty much gives me the impression it only helps attack. -- Adie
Q.O.W. -- I would be amazed if you would receive +4 in each area for a favorite weapon. And we do not believe the fave adds to the speed with the weapon. The fave greatly aids attack and parry, hit %, and ability to hold onto the weapon. And, of course, criticals increase. -- Kennelworth
Hanibal -- I don't know about specific bonuses for using a favored weapon. However, I do believe that if your favored weapon is something that you aren't otherwise suited for (for example, a broadsword for someone lacking the necessary attributes), you can often get good results by going for a lower version of that weapon. From the halberd of your example, for instance, "down" to a great axe, or even farther down to battle axe and then to hatchet. Experiment with them and see what might work. I have no specific numbers to support this, but it is the impression I've gathered over the cycles. -- Leeta